Showing posts with label South Yorkshire People's Network. Show all posts
Showing posts with label South Yorkshire People's Network. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 November 2026

South Yorkshire People's Network Initial Doncaster Proposals

A brief diversion from reviewing Stagecoach's September changes in Hull, and a look at what South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority (SYMCA) are proposing once they franchise services in Doncaster next year, as part of their South Yorkshire People's Network - and in particular how it impacts services into North Lincolnshire.

The full details for Doncaster can be accessed here.

Starting with the main route from North Lincolnshire into Doncaster, the 399 from Scunthorpe to Doncaster via the Isle of Axholme. Here a logical outcome occurs, especially given the route is operated from the Scunthorpe end of the route and is part funded by North Lincolnshire Council:

399 (New No. 399) Doncaster city centre – Scunthorpe

The 399 will not be franchised because it mostly runs outside South Yorkshire, but will be allowed to continue running into Doncaster under a special permit scheme.

Next I want to mention a service that doesn't actually enter North Lincolnshire at all, the current 98 from Gainsborough to Doncaster via West Stockwith and Bawtry. I mention West Stockwith very deliberately...

98 (New No. 398) Doncaster city centre – Gainborough

The 98 will be re-numbered 398 to match the ‘300s’ numbering group in Doncaster. 

The 398 will not be franchised because it mostly runs outside South Yorkshire, but will be allowed to continue running into Doncaster under a special permit scheme. 

It may make sense from a Doncaster perspective to renumber, but what about the 'numbering group' around Beckingham, Walkeringham, West Stockwith and Misterton? Here you currently have the 97 and 98 as the main services, each every two hours or approximately hourly combined. The 97 is also coordinated with the 95 between Gainsborough, Beckingham and Retford. 

There is also another issue. Between Gainsborough and West Stockwith there is already a service 398 - the Tuesday and Friday 398 'shopper service' from Belton to Gainsborough. 

It all feels like SYMCA haven't fully considered the implications beyond South Yorkshire. 

Now it maybe that renumbering the 97 to 397 is the easiest way to tidy things up in Gainsborough and Bassetlaw. Or that a twice weekly shopper service shouldn't be allowed to prevent the renumbering of a two hourly six day a week service. However it is disappointing that SYMCA haven't publicly acknowledged the out of area issues they are going to create - particularly the two 398's between Gainsborough and West Stockwith. They are trying to remove duplicate route numbers within South Yorkshire, then create a duplicate route number elsewhere! A 'we aware that an existing 398 services already operates over part of the route and are in discussions about this' would be welcome.

In this instance I'm not so sure that the 398 is the best number anyway. The other Bawtry to Doncaster services will be the 321, 325, 328 and 329. 326 or 330 could be a better choice than 398?

Now back to links from the Isle of Axholme into Doncaster, and in particular the Thursday, Friday and Saturday evening service, currently provided from Doncaster as an extension of South Yorkshire local service 359, and back into Doncaster as service 360.

359 (New No. n/a) Doncaster – Epworth

Evening and Sunday journeys currently numbered 359 will be variously replaced by the 355/356 on the Bawtry Road, the 357 in Auckley and Finningley, the 358 in West Bessacarr, and the 398 in Westwoodside, Haxey and Epworth. 

360 (New No. n/a) Doncaster – Epworth

Evening journeys currently numbered 360 will be replaced by the 357 in Cantley, Auckley and Finningley, and by the 398 in Westwoodside, Haxey and Epworth.

Firstly there does appear to be an error here. Surely it should be '399 in Westwoodside, Haxey and Epworth' not the 398? Typos aside, my interpretation is that SYMCA are saying that any evening services between Doncaster and the Isle of Axholme will have to be on service 399 and totally separate from the franchised People's Network? I get their desire for route simplification, but hopefully they will be helpful and supportive in facilitating a replacement.

On the surface, the current 359 extension appears quite efficient. Rather than a dedicated service from Doncaster to Epworth, simply extend an existing route between Doncaster and Finningley onto Epworth. However every time a 359 extends beyond Finningley to Epworth, another vehicle has to run out of service to Finningley in order to work a Finningley to Doncaster service. So it probably wouldn't be significantly more inefficient to operate an evening service 399.

Hopefully the evening link from the Isle of Axholme into Doncaster can be continued in some way - and maybe even extended to Scunthorpe - but clearly change is coming.